Radley Balko and David
Zinczenko accidentally bump into each other in front of a McDonalds when walking
around a shopping center.
Radley: “Hey, I’m sorry, I didn’t
see you there.”
David: “No, it’s okay, don’t worry
about it.”
Radley: “Hey, aren’t you David Zinczenko; the
editor-in-chief of Men’s Health and
the author of Eat This, Not That?”
David: “Yes, that’s me. I recognize you too. You’re Radley Balko; the
senior editor of Reason. “
Radley: “I’d love to talk to you
about food habits. Do you have a few minutes?”
David:” Sure, where do you want to
talk?”
Radley: “Well, ironically, we’re in front of a McDonald’s. I
think that’s the perfect place to discuss food habits.”
David: “Ok, let’s go in there, but
I am just getting water.”
Radley: “Same here.”
Radley and David get
water and sit down at a table inside McDonalds.
David: “Would you look at all these poor children and their
parents. Most of them are overweight and they continue to eat these high-calorie
foods without even knowing how many calories they’re in taking. This is why the
government should intervene when it comes to having health care for people who
do have medical problems caused by obesity.”
Radley: “What do you mean?”
David: “What I’m saying is that it is difficult for people
to live a healthy life style. They’re thousands of McDonald’s around, but where
can they go to find a grapefruit? These fast-food companies don’t even show the
costumers how many calories are in the food they are consuming. In the past
eight years, medical problems caused by obesity, like Type 2 diabetes, has more
than tripled in the percentage of children who have it. ”
Radley: “So you’re saying that these children are being
pulled into going to these fast-food restaurants when there is not time to make
meals because they are so available and that the government has to pay for the
people who have medical problems due to obesity?”
David: “Exactly! The fast-food companies are luring children
into their fast-food restaurants by giving them toys in their happy meals that
don’t have warning labels even though these products do have proven health
hazards. The government must pay for their illnesses because they’re not many
alternatives to buying fast-food and there is not much information about what
they are eating provided to them”
Radley: “I disagree with you David. I believe that since
these adults are giving their children and themselves unhealthy food on a daily
basis that they should face the consequences by paying for their own medical
protection.”
David: “Why do you believe this?”
Radley: “More and more over the years, America’s health care
system is helping with more socialist issues. The way people take care of
themselves has become a problem to the public health system.”
David: “How is this possible?”
Radley: “Democratic candidates keep pushing health care
coverage for all citizens. Now, when people get heart disease and need
anti-cholesterol medication, the government is paying for it.
David: “So you believe that nothing is stopping people from
making bad choices because the government will just pay for them.”
Radley: “Exactly! People will continue to make bad choices
if they don’t have to pay for it. If people actually had to pay for health
care, they would stop making bad choices and eat healthier.”
David: “Even though I do not agree with your argument, I
still believe it is valid. I really enjoyed talking to you Radley, but I have
to get going now.”
Radley: “I feel the same way
towards your argument. I enjoyed talking to you too!”
Radley
and David leave McDonald’s.
Thesis Statement: All people should get free health care
when having illnesses for any and all reasons. People don't become obese
because they know they won't have to pay for their health care but because they
enjoy eating and have an addiction to food. They're not thinking about the
consequence of having to pay for their illness if they get one.
I like how you started the dialogue with the two authors introducing each other and stating their credentials. I found it amusing that you placed the two authors in McDonald's as it will bring fire to their discussion. I like how you pointed out the fact Radley believes individuals will stop making bad food decisions if they paid for healthcare. I do not agree with Radley since if the people who can't afford to buy anything else than a burger from the dollar menu, how can they even afford a proper health care? Even though we do live in a society that praises individuality, we can't just leave those who don't have the resources to take care of themselves to their own demise. I also enjoyed that you ended the conversation in a friendly matter; although both were strong advocates for their belief, they were able to accept the other's opinion and appreciate the other's company. I agree with your thesis statement in that there should be free health care provided for people. As previously stated, not everyone are in a financial situation where they can afford health care. The government should implement alternatives and provide people with more information about the foods they are eating.
ReplyDelete